Ethics in publishing
PUBLICATION ETHICS POLICY
- General Principles
The editorial office of O‘zbekiston arxeologiyasi (Archaeology of Uzbekistan) opposes all forms of unethical conduct, plagiarism, fabrication and falsification of research data, improper duplicate publication, manipulation of authorship, concealment of conflicts of interest and other breaches of academic integrity.
Preventing, identifying and properly addressing such breaches are among the principal responsibilities of the editorial office, the Editorial Board and the publisher.
The editorial office follows:
- the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE);
- international standards of research and publication ethics;
- the recommendations of the Publishing Ethics Resource Kit (PERK);
- the legislation of the Republic of Uzbekistan in force;
- the journal’s editorial policy and internal documents.
Reference to the recommendations of COPE and PERK does not imply membership of these organisations unless such membership has been formally obtained.
The journal’s ethical standards apply to all participants in the publication process:
- authors;
- reviewers;
- the Editor-in-Chief;
- members of the Editorial Board and Editorial Council;
- editorial staff;
- the publisher;
- invited experts;
- translators and technical editors.
- Originality Check
Before being sent for scholarly peer review, all submitted manuscripts are checked for textual similarities and possible improper borrowing using StrikePlagiarism.com.
The system report is an auxiliary tool for editorial assessment. The percentage of textual similarity alone is not conclusive evidence of the presence or absence of plagiarism.
The editorial office assesses:
- the nature of the similarities identified;
- the presence of correct references;
- the extent of verbatim borrowing;
- the use of standard scholarly formulations;
- the particularities of descriptions of archaeological materials;
- similarities in methodological sections;
- the author’s reuse of their own previously published text;
- the lawful use of tables, figures, maps and photographs.
Where questionable similarities are identified, the editorial office may:
- request an explanation from the author;
- require correction of the text and references;
- send the material for additional expert assessment;
- reject the manuscript;
- notify the author’s institution where a serious breach is identified;
- apply a correction or retraction procedure if the breach is discovered after publication.
- Principal Forms of Breach of Publication Ethics
Breaches of publication and research ethics include:
- plagiarism;
- self-plagiarism and improper reuse of one’s own text;
- duplicate or parallel publication;
- simultaneous submission of the same manuscript to several journals;
- fabrication of data;
- falsification of results;
- manipulation of images;
- presentation of non-existent archaeological materials;
- false attribution of the provenance of finds;
- alteration or concealment of archaeological context;
- use of fictitious sources and bibliographic references;
- unlawful use of other persons’ photographs, maps, tables and drawings;
- appropriation of the results of another researcher or expedition;
- unjustified inclusion of a person as an author;
- exclusion from authorship of a person who made a substantial contribution;
- concealment of a conflict of interest;
- abuse of self-citation;
- coercive citation;
- manipulation of the peer-review procedure;
- undeclared use of artificial intelligence;
- breach of the conditions of access to museum, archival or collection materials.
ETHICS OF PUBLISHING SCHOLARLY ARTICLES
- Requirements for Published Materials
Original scholarly materials are accepted for consideration where they:
- have not previously been published in full or in substantial part;
- are not simultaneously under consideration by another publication;
- contain reliable research results;
- correspond to the scope of the journal;
- possess scholarly novelty;
- are based on verifiable sources and materials;
- are prepared in accordance with the Guidelines for Authors;
- comply with the standards of research and publication ethics.
Materials are not accepted where they contain:
- plagiarism;
- unlawful use of the results of other researchers;
- substantial duplication of previously published work;
- fabricated or distorted data;
- unreliable bibliographic information;
- materials of unknown or illegal provenance;
- copyright violations.
A preprint, conference abstract or brief preliminary report is not necessarily regarded as prior publication if the author openly discloses its existence, provides a reference and substantially expands the research results. The editorial office makes an individual decision in each case.
- Criteria for Editorial Decisions
A decision to accept or reject a manuscript is based on the following criteria:
- conformity with the journal’s scope;
- scholarly significance;
- originality;
- relevance;
- reliability of materials;
- validity of methods;
- quality of argumentation;
- correspondence of the conclusions to the results obtained;
- clarity of presentation;
- compliance with publication ethics;
- reports of independent reviewers.
Commercial, administrative, personal and other extraneous interests must not influence publication decisions.
Positive reviews do not result in automatic acceptance of an article. The final decision is made by the Editorial Board.
- Free Publication
The journal does not charge fees for:
- manuscript submission;
- formatting checks;
- originality checks;
- scholarly peer review;
- editorial processing;
- publication of an article;
- making materials openly accessible.
No royalties are paid for published research articles, surveys, reviews or reports.
The absence of fees does not affect the independence of peer review or editorial decisions.
- Editorial Independence
The editorial office makes decisions independently of:
- the founder;
- sponsors;
- advertisers;
- public or private organisations;
- the author’s professional status;
- personal relationships;
- commercial interests.
The founder and publisher must not interfere in the assessment of the scholarly content of a particular manuscript.
Editorial decisions are based on the scholarly quality of the material and its conformity with journal policy.
- Non-Discrimination
The editorial office assesses manuscripts without discriminating against authors on the basis of:
- sex;
- age;
- race;
- ethnic origin;
- citizenship;
- language;
- religious beliefs;
- political views;
- social status;
- position;
- academic degree;
- place of employment;
- any other characteristic unrelated to the scholarly quality of the manuscript.
- Confidentiality
The editorial office ensures the confidentiality of the manuscript at every stage of consideration.
Unpublished materials may not be:
- disclosed to unauthorised persons;
- used by editors or reviewers in their own research;
- discussed publicly;
- copied or distributed without the author’s permission.
Access to a manuscript is restricted to persons directly involved in its consideration, verification and preparation for publication.
Exceptions are permitted where necessary for:
- additional peer review;
- investigation of an alleged breach;
- verification of copyright;
- contacting the author’s institution;
- compliance with legal requirements.
- Integrity of the Author’s Text
The editorial office may carry out:
- scholarly editing;
- language and stylistic editing;
- proofreading;
- standardisation of terminology;
- technical formatting;
- correction of bibliographic entries;
- preparation of metadata;
- processing of tables and illustrations.
Changes must not distort the author’s scholarly position, materials, results or conclusions.
Substantial changes to content are agreed with the corresponding author.
Spelling, punctuation and technical corrections may be made without separate approval of every change.
- Consideration of Complaints and Reports of Misconduct
The editorial office considers reasoned submissions concerning:
- submitted manuscripts;
- published articles;
- the conduct of editors;
- the conduct of reviewers;
- authorship;
- plagiarism;
- conflicts of interest;
- reliability of data;
- copyright violations;
- the peer-review procedure.
A submission must contain a specific description of the problem and, where possible, supporting materials.
The editorial office undertakes to:
- register the submission;
- conduct a preliminary review;
- provide interested parties with an opportunity to give an explanation;
- involve independent experts where necessary;
- make a reasoned decision;
- notify the complainant and the author of the outcome to the extent permitted.
- Corrections and Retractions
If errors or breaches are identified after publication, the editorial office may:
- publish a correction;
- publish an addendum;
- issue an expression of concern;
- retract the article;
- remove the material in exceptional legal circumstances.
Decisions are made in accordance with the Policy on Corrections, Addenda and Retractions posted on the journal website.
The editorial office accepts responsibility for its own errors and, where necessary, publishes corrections, clarifications or apologies.
- Responsibility for Content
Authors are responsible for the reliability of materials, the accuracy of references and the content of conclusions.
The editorial office and publisher do not necessarily share the scholarly assessments, interpretations and conclusions of authors of published materials.
Publication of an article does not constitute official endorsement by the editorial office of every position expressed by the author.
ETHICS FOR AUTHORS OF SCHOLARLY PUBLICATIONS
- Reliability of Research
An author must present reliable and accurately described results.
The manuscript must provide information that makes it possible to assess:
- the provenance of materials;
- the research methods;
- the conditions under which data were obtained;
- the logic of the analysis;
- the validity of the interpretations;
- the correspondence of the conclusions to the results presented.
The author must not:
- fabricate data;
- alter results in order to support a hypothesis;
- exclude inconvenient data without scholarly explanation;
- present assumptions as established facts;
- conceal limitations of the research.
- Archaeological Materials and Provenance of Finds
The author must accurately specify:
- the site and place where the materials were found;
- the archaeological context;
- the number of the trench, feature, layer or burial;
- inventory and collection numbers;
- the location where the finds are stored;
- information on permission to conduct the research;
- the organisation or expedition that obtained the materials;
- the source of archival or museum information.
Publication of materials obtained in the following ways is not permitted:
- as a result of illegal excavations;
- from illicit trafficking in cultural property;
- without the consent of the collection owner;
- in breach of the conditions of access to an archive or collection repository;
- with intentionally false information about provenance.
Where necessary to protect an archaeological site, the editorial office may restrict publication of its precise coordinates.
- Originality
The author warrants that the manuscript:
- is original;
- has not previously been published in full or in substantial part;
- has not been submitted simultaneously to another publication;
- contains no unattributed borrowing;
- is not a minimally altered version of a previously published article.
All borrowed ideas, texts, data and images must be accompanied by appropriate references.
Verbatim quotation must be formatted as a quotation and identify the source and page.
Paraphrasing another person’s text without a reference also constitutes misconduct.
- Reuse of a Published Article
After publication, the author may not submit the same material to another publication as a new and previously unpublished article.
At the same time, the author retains the right to:
- use the results in a dissertation;
- include the material in a monograph;
- deposit the published version in a repository;
- use the article for teaching purposes;
- publish a translation;
- distribute the material in accordance with the journal’s licence.
Any reuse must identify the place of first publication in O‘zbekiston arxeologiyasi.
- Self-Plagiarism and Duplication
An author must cite their own previously published work when reusing its:
- text;
- data;
- tables;
- illustrations;
- conclusions;
- descriptions of materials.
The following are not permitted:
- republication of a substantial part of the text without citation;
- artificial division of one study into several similar articles;
- publication of the same set of results under different titles;
- concealment of a previously published version of the research.
- Authorship
Only persons who have made a substantial intellectual contribution to the following are included as authors:
- formulation of the research concept;
- acquisition of materials;
- development of the methodology;
- data analysis;
- interpretation of results;
- preparation or substantive editing of the text.
The following are not permitted:
- honorary authorship;
- gift authorship;
- inclusion of a supervisor solely on the basis of their position;
- exclusion of an actual author;
- identification of a fictitious author;
- inclusion of a person without their consent.
Persons who provided technical, administrative or financial assistance may be named in the “Acknowledgements” section.
For multi-authored articles, author contributions should be stated in accordance with the CRediT taxonomy.
- Co-Author Consent
The corresponding author must confirm that:
- all co-authors have reviewed the final version;
- all agree to submission of the article;
- the order of authors has been agreed;
- all authors are responsible for their part of the work;
- all authors have accepted the terms of publication.
Changes to the list or order of authors after submission are permitted only with the written consent of all participants.
- Conflict of Interest
An author must disclose any circumstances that could influence, or create the appearance of influencing, the research results.
Conflicts of interest may include:
- financial interests;
- employment relationships;
- participation in competing projects;
- personal relationships;
- administrative dependency;
- expert or consultancy activities;
- ownership of rights in the materials under study;
- interests of the funding organisation.
Where there is no conflict of interest, the following statement is provided:
Conflict of interest. The author declares that there is no conflict of interest.
- Funding
The author must specify:
- the source of funding;
- the project or grant number;
- the organisation that provided the funds;
- the sponsor’s role in the research;
- whether the sponsor influenced the preparation of the article.
Where the research received no specific funding, this must be stated separately.
- Use of Third-Party Materials
The author must obtain the necessary permissions to publish:
- photographs;
- museum objects;
- archival documents;
- maps;
- drawings;
- tables;
- reconstructions;
- unpublished data;
- other protected materials.
A written or oral communication from another researcher may be used only with their consent and with appropriate acknowledgement.
- Errors after Submission and Publication
If an author discovers a significant error:
- in a manuscript under consideration;
- in an accepted article;
- in an article already published,
they must notify the editorial office immediately.
The author must cooperate with the editorial office in preparing:
- a correction;
- an addendum;
- an error notice;
- a retraction.
Concealment of a significant error known to the author is regarded as a breach of publication ethics.
- Responses to Reviewer Comments
The author must carefully consider the comments of reviewers and the editorial office.
When revising an article, the author must:
- make justified corrections;
- prepare a response to each comment;
- identify where changes were made;
- explain the reasons for disagreeing with individual recommendations.
An author may disagree with a reviewer, but objections must be scientifically substantiated and expressed appropriately.
- Scholarly Criticism
Scholarly discussion must be conducted respectfully.
The following are not permitted:
- personal attacks;
- insults;
- unsupported accusations;
- discriminatory statements;
- deliberate distortion of another researcher’s position.
Criticism must address methods, materials, arguments and conclusions rather than the author personally.
- Copyright and Licence
Authors retain copyright in their works.
After an article has been accepted, the author grants the publisher the non-exclusive right of first publication in print and electronic form.
The full texts of articles are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence — CC BY-NC 4.0.
The author may deposit an electronic copy of the article in repositories and on personal scholarly resources, provided that the place of first publication is identified.
The terms of use of an article are governed in detail by the Licence Agreement and the “Copyright and Licensing Policy” section.
- Translation of an Article
If an official translation of an article is prepared by the editorial office, its text is agreed with the author before publication. Third-party translations are governed by the terms of the CC BY-NC 4.0 licence.
After publication, the author may use the original and translated versions, provided that the following are stated:
- the journal;
- the year and issue;
- the pages;
- the DOI;
- the language of first publication.
ETHICS OF PEER REVIEW OF SCHOLARLY PUBLICATIONS
- Independence of Peer Review
Peer review must be objective and independent of:
- commercial interests;
- personal relationships;
- administrative pressure;
- scholarly competition;
- the author’s national or institutional affiliation.
The priority criteria are:
- scholarly value;
- novelty;
- reliability;
- quality of methodology;
- validity of conclusions;
- conformity with the journal’s scope.
- Confidentiality of Peer Review
A reviewer must treat the manuscript as a confidential document.
The reviewer may not:
- pass it to another person;
- use unpublished data;
- retain materials for personal use;
- discuss the article outside the peer-review process;
- disclose information about the progress of consideration.
If another specialist needs to be involved, the reviewer must obtain permission from the editorial office.
- Objectivity of the Review
The reviewer must provide:
- an objective assessment;
- reasoned comments;
- specific recommendations;
- a clear conclusion on whether publication is possible.
Personal criticism of the author is not permitted.
Comments must concern the manuscript’s content, methods, sources, results, structure and formatting.
- Reviewer Conflict of Interest
A reviewer must decline to assess an article if they:
- work with the author in the same organisation or unit;
- have recently been a co-author of the author;
- are the author’s academic supervisor or student;
- participate in the same project;
- have a personal or financial interest;
- compete with the author for scholarly priority;
- cannot ensure objectivity.
If in doubt, the reviewer must notify the editor.
- Reviewer Competence
A specialist must decline to review if:
- the topic lies outside their expertise;
- they are unfamiliar with the methods applied;
- they cannot assess the language of the manuscript;
- they cannot prepare the report within the established period.
- Prohibition of Coercive Citation
A reviewer must not require citation of:
- their own works;
- works of a particular research group;
- publications of a particular journal,
unless they are directly relevant to the content of the article.
Recommendations for additional literature must be scientifically justified.
- Identification of Misconduct
If a reviewer identifies signs of:
- plagiarism;
- duplicate publication;
- fabrication or falsification;
- image manipulation;
- fictitious references;
- illegal provenance of materials;
- copyright violations;
- an undeclared conflict of interest,
they must report this confidentially to the Editor-in-Chief.
The reviewer must not publicly accuse the author independently.
- Reviewer’s Recommendation
The reviewer may recommend:
- accepting the article without substantial changes;
- accepting it after minor revision;
- requesting major revision;
- sending it for additional peer review;
- rejecting the manuscript.
The reviewer’s recommendation is advisory.
The final decision is made by the Editorial Board.
ETHICS FOR EDITORS AND THE PUBLISHER
- Responsibilities of the Editor
The editor must:
- ensure fair consideration of manuscripts;
- maintain confidentiality;
- appoint competent and independent reviewers;
- identify conflicts of interest;
- not use unpublished materials;
- consider reports of misconduct;
- ensure the possibility of appeal;
- take measures to correct the scholarly record;
- protect editorial independence.
- Manuscript by an Editor or Editorial Board Member
If the author of an article is:
- the Editor-in-Chief;
- the Deputy Editor-in-Chief;
- a member of the Editorial Board;
- a member of the editorial staff,
that author does not participate in selecting reviewers, discussing the manuscript or making the decision.
The consideration is organised by an independent editor with no conflict of interest.
- Responsibilities of the Publisher
The publisher must:
- support editorial independence;
- ensure the technical operation of the journal;
- facilitate the preservation of scholarly documentation;
- refrain from exerting pressure on editorial decisions;
- support correction and retraction procedures;
- ensure transparency of publication terms;
- protect the personal data of participants in the process.
POLICY ON THE USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
- General Requirements
Artificial intelligence may not be named as an author or co-author.
Authors bear full responsibility for:
- the accuracy of the text;
- the reliability of the data;
- the accuracy of references;
- the absence of plagiarism;
- the content of the conclusions;
- maintenance of confidentiality.
- Disclosure of AI Use
If artificial intelligence tools were used in preparing an article, the author must specify:
- the name of the tool;
- the purpose for which it was used;
- the part of the work in which it was used;
- how the output was checked by a human.
Ordinary spelling and formatting functions need not be disclosed if they do not generate substantive text.
- Prohibited Use of AI
Artificial intelligence may not be used for:
- creating fabricated data;
- generating non-existent sources;
- producing false archaeological images;
- replacing independent scholarly analysis;
- concealing plagiarism;
- breaching manuscript confidentiality;
- processing restricted museum or archival data without permission.
Editors and reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts to publicly accessible artificial intelligence systems without appropriate permission and safeguards for information protection.
ADVERTISING AND SPONSORSHIP POLICY
- Editorial Independence from Advertising
Advertising materials and sponsorship support must not influence:
- selection of articles;
- appointment of reviewers;
- peer-review outcomes;
- publication decisions;
- the content of scholarly materials;
- the order in which articles are placed.
The journal does not publish scholarly materials prepared solely to accompany a particular advertisement.
- Separation of Advertising from Editorial Materials
Advertising and informational materials must:
- be clearly identified as advertising;
- be visually separated from scholarly articles;
- not mislead the reader;
- not imitate editorial materials;
- not be associated with an editorial recommendation.
Advertising must not be placed in a way that creates the impression that the editorial office endorses a particular product, service or organisation.
- Unacceptable Advertising
The editorial office may refuse to place materials that:
- conflict with the journal’s scope or reputation;
- contain unreliable information;
- violate the law;
- infringe the rights of third parties;
- discriminate against individuals or groups;
- may harm cultural heritage;
- create a conflict with editorial independence.
- Advertising Decisions
Organisational decisions on the placement of advertising are made by the publisher.
The Editor-in-Chief may object to the placement of advertising material if it:
- creates a conflict of interest;
- threatens editorial independence;
- conflicts with publication ethics;
- is capable of misleading readers.
Income from advertising or sponsorship must not be linked to the acceptance of a particular article.
CONSIDERATION OF MISCONDUCT
- Investigation Procedure
Upon receiving information about possible misconduct, the editorial office:
- registers the report;
- conducts a preliminary review;
- notifies interested parties;
- requests explanations and original materials;
- involves independent experts where necessary;
- considers the matter at the Editorial Board;
- makes a decision;
- notifies the author and complainant.
The investigation is conducted confidentially and respects the participants’ right to provide explanations.
- Possible Measures
Depending on the nature of the breach, the editorial office may:
- issue a warning;
- require correction of the manuscript;
- reject the article;
- terminate consideration;
- prohibit resubmission of unchanged material;
- publish a correction;
- issue an expression of concern;
- retract the article;
- notify the author’s institution;
- notify the editorial office of another journal;
- contact the rights holder or funding organisation.
Measures must be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the breach.
- Appeal
An author, reviewer or other interested person may appeal an editorial decision.
The appeal must:
- be submitted in writing;
- contain specific arguments;
- identify possible procedural errors;
- be accompanied by supporting materials.
The appeal is considered by the Editor-in-Chief, the Editorial Board or an independent expert with no conflict of interest.
- Final Provision
By submitting a manuscript to O‘zbekiston arxeologiyasi, the author confirms that they have read and agree to this Publication Ethics Policy.
The editorial office undertakes to continuously improve its procedures and to consider all substantiated reports of possible misconduct before and after publication.