Article Peer Review Procedure
Article Peer Review Procedure
- All research articles that comply with the journal’s scope and formal requirements undergo mandatory scholarly peer review. Before being sent to experts, the manuscript undergoes editorial and technical screening.
- The manuscript is sent to at least two independent specialists with expertise in the research topic and recent publications in the relevant field. Reviewers may be affiliated with the publisher’s institution or with other research institutions.
- The journal applies double-blind peer review: authors are not informed of the reviewers’ identities, and reviewers are not given the authors’ names or affiliations. All communication between authors and reviewers takes place exclusively through the editorial office.
- A reviewer must notify the editor of any actual or potential conflict of interest and decline to review the manuscript if they cannot provide an independent and objective assessment.
- The standard review period is up to four weeks. If a reviewer cannot prepare the report within the established period, they must notify the editorial office promptly.
- The manuscript is assessed for scholarly novelty, relevance, reliability of materials, validity of methods and conclusions, quality of source use, compliance with ethical standards, logic of structure, quality of illustrations and conformity with the journal’s scope.
- The reviewer submits a reasoned report and one of the following recommendations:
accept the article without substantial changes;
accept after minor revision;
request major revision and repeat peer review;
send for additional peer review;
reject the manuscript.
- If the reports of the two reviewers differ substantially, the editorial office sends the manuscript to a third independent specialist or considers the matter at a meeting of the Editorial Board.
- When revising the manuscript, the author submits the corrected text and a separate response to every reviewer comment, indicating the changes made or providing a scholarly justification for disagreement.
- A negative report from one reviewer does not automatically result in rejection. The final decision is made by the Editorial Board on the basis of the combined expert reports and the author’s responses.
- The author may submit a reasoned appeal against an editorial decision. The appeal is considered by an editor or independent expert who did not participate in the original decision and has no conflict of interest.
- Reviews and related editorial documents are retained by the editorial office for at least five years. Unpublished materials and information obtained during peer review are confidential and may not be used for personal benefit.